THIN GREEN LINE
Duncan Wilson

How do we illustrate dominance? What about authority? And what are the downstream effects of information—and ideology—deployed with these visual cues in mind? In this text, machine learning specialist Duncan Wilson unpacks the recent "Don't Lean In" meme as well as a critical development in the aesthetic conventions of the highly online right, warning of the possible mass cultural implications of this shift.  — NM

THIN GREEN LINE

RECENTLY, A FRIEND sent me this meme.

I asked around and found @Rivelino to be the initial poster. (A whole piece should be written on how shitty that account is, but that’s for someone else.) See below for the first usage I could find (at right) and the reasoning behind it (at left).

Given that there are TEDtalks on the right power postures for excelling at service jobs that won't ever pay enough to let you own a house or raise children, the "Don't Lean In" meme is hardly more ridiculous. In my view, this meme and other dominance hierarchy memes that reach the mainstream after originating in this heavily online community (e.g., the Virgin v. Chad meme and its variants) are often: 1. hilarious, 2. semi-accurate if you squint your eyes at society enough, and 3. largely benign. Here's the Virgin vs. Chad meme getting posture-checked.

But why should anyone care about people on Twitter drawing green lines on photos of other people? Generally, they shouldn’t. Essentially, this is just another iteration of the alpha/beta dominance hierarchy format that is ubiquitous within heavily online communities. As artist Joshua Citarella pointed out, however, the aesthetics of the Don’t Lean In format—green lines generalizing the relative positioning of figures in an image—has a lot in common with how computer vision algorithms are often displayed. I find this as good an opportunity as any to discuss the systematizing design reasoning that increasingly appears linked to the incel-adjacent online world and the way in which its generally regressive ideology may be gaining visibility and acceptance in the mainstream. As someone who works in machine learning, I can’t help but think about how the green lines in the Don’t Lean In memes are similar to an old school computer vision preprocessing technique called morphological skeletalization.

At a high level, this works by iteratively scanning an image and eroding the borders of each object pictured, pixel by pixel, until only a single line of pixels remains. This same process can also be useful in recovering line data from corrupted images such as fingerprints (the canonical example). Also relevant here: the applied field of computer vision that is skeletal body tracking.

But the meme also contains strong aesthetic links to the field of machine learning. Image classifiers often utilize a pure green bounding box to denote the region of interest containing the image's target object.

As this same green features prominently in the corporate branding for the company I work with, I asked the founder what significance or use-value he felt it held.

Looking deeper, I found that the human eye is actually more sensitive to certain pigments, and pure green the most. This is because the photoreceptors in human eyes are unevenly distributed across the visible light spectrum. By contrast, birds and bees have more evenly spaced receptors—and therefore more equal sensitivity to different tones.

The evolutionary reason we developed this kind of vision (called asymmetric trichromatic vision and shared by all primates) is thought to be for how it helps us identify small differences within a wide range of plants: for example, to better determine when fruit is ripe or what is or isn't edible. There is also a compelling explanation regarding primates’ sensitivity to red pigments, which is useful for social coordination (blushing, being red with anger, pulling a whitey).

In 2019, Kate Crawford and Trevor Paglen launched a viral, facial recognition app called ImageNet Roulette. Matching the aesthetic conventions of the machine learning field, the app used pure green (RGB schema 0,255,0) to draw the bounding box around the user’s face on screen. (Likely, green is the default selection color for computer vision systems not only because it is so easy to specify, but also for how easy it is for the human eye to see when overlaid on any other given image). From there, the app would assign you to a class,  with labels from the innocuous and inane (anchorperson, skier, healthy) to the blunt and problematic (kept-woman, money-grubber, slave), which it had inferred from your image. Users were left to debate what about their visual appearance caused the algorithm to assign the specific class it did. Of course the point of Crawford and Paglen’s work, at least in part, was to demonstrate what biases get hardwired into the process of mechanical “understanding” of images from human generated labels. For me, seeing it pop up as a face filter on Instagram solidified this connection between the seeming authority of a solid green bounding box and mechanical judgement.

I think it’s important to contrast the rising ubiquity of mechanical judgement with the original Mechanical Turk, a truly impressive 18th century parlor trick involving an “automatic” chess opponent (after which Amazon named its b2c slave-labor-as-a-service). Created in the latter half of the 1700s by Wolfgang von Kempelen, a Hungarian civil servant, the contraption worked via a series of levers, magnets, and strings, allowing a human operator to hide inside its candlelit wooden box and control the attached "robot" to play a game of chess. The operator’s seat could even be moved around so that prior to a demonstration, nearly all of the doors of the machine could be opened revealing only gears, pulleys, and empty space, ensuring that the illusion was convincing.

After debuting the machine at the Austrian royal court, Kempelen toured it around Europe before passing it along to other owners. With a skilled operator inside, the Turk could win most games, including with such notable losers as Ben Franklin and Napoleon (who tested the machine by cheating multiple times during his games). Even Gary Kasperov's knee-jerk reaction was to claim there had to be chess grand masters secretly remote-operating Deep Blue when he started to lose after game 2 of the 1997 rematch.

While the roots lay in these earlier events, it feels like there has been an inflection point in people’s confidence in technology’s “judgement” within my lifetime: one that budded with the machine recognition of cats in Youtube videos and blossomed with 18-time world champion Go master Lee Sedol losing to Google DeepMind’s AlphaGo. The shift we’ve witnessed is humans now placing trust in a system not for producing results that we can confirm to be true (cats) but for producing results that are explicitly beyond the human capacity to independently verify. We have come to grant a system value because, not in spite, its use of artificial intelligence.

In short, we can think of this shift as an appeal to algorithmic supremacy.

In Silicon Valley, this is not a new trend. Since ~2015, founders have had better chances of raising rounds of funding by claiming their system to be "AI." A 2019 report from MMC Ventures found that companies labeled “AI” on Crunchbase-like sites for European start-ups, attracted between 15 to 50% more funding. The same report found that roughly 40% of these companies in fact had absolutely no true AI at all at the core of their IP! (Fwiw: in a market that will support an AI powered toothbrush, there is little incentive for founders to correct the tagging if mislabeled as an AI company. They’ll get there eventually, right? Growth mindset!)[1]

As this appeal has spilled beyond the zone of Modafinil-fueled pitches to VCs and into the Overton window, I see this 'appeal to algorithmic supremacy' providing two rhetorical functions: 1. no matter which conclusion is reached, the result is given more authority due to the fact that it’s come from a computational process rather than the irrational depths of the human mind; and 2. any fault in the conclusion is shifted away from the presenter, allowing them to shrug and reply, “It’s what the machine says!”

It is extremely unlikely that @Rivalino thought through this string of connections before making the first Don’t Lean In meme. Probably, the aesthetic choices were even subconscious. And yet they nevertheless channel a much larger trend of hyper-systematic thinking that I have been seeing grow in this online space. It’s important to stress that, for a lot of incels, “not having sex” may be what initially brings them to the community, but what many stay for is a collective acceptance of (or even obsession with) the seemingly hard realities of dominance hiearchies in society. And it’s understandable how, when faced with a process as complex as socialization, there’s this desire to just formulate your thesis via two green lines. In fact, quantitative thinking-driven reasoning isn’t even what we need to worry about with this crowd. The whole logic is so self-limiting and rigid that it hardly has broad appeal. (If you don’t know what I mean, go on incel.wiki and see the obsessive love of systematizing for yourself.)

Decile Scale via incels.wiki

Of course this, too, is nothing new. But what does feel novel to me, or at least like something that I’ve only recently noticed, is how different parts of these highly online, right-adjacent circles have become markedly more aware of their aesthetic strategy. I'm thinking, here, of such Gen-Z heirs to Mencius-Moldbug-style neo-reactionary discourse as Kantbot, whatever that perfume guy's name is, BAP, and that Twitter with stock-photo-esque images of beaches and attractive women interspersed with the occasional image-plus-antisemitic-caption of a buff white guy.[2] (There are also some old NRx Tumblrs of architecture that precede all of this but they’re too rinsed by now to include).

Before saying more, I want to be clear that I have no interest in giving these figures any kind of special importance and I sincerely do not wish to platform them. (To at least minimize the signal boost, screenshots in this piece omit usernames.) There is, however, something going on here worth observing—an advanced version of the systematically-minded design thinking of incel communities, which is being applied to what remains a generally regressive set of trad values (i.e., the racial prejudice and gender norms of the “simpler” pre-modern time they prize).

Complicating this is that the memes that circulate in this world tend to rely on many layers of irony and meta-irony. So my guess is that their core values end up remaining largely opaque to everyone who shares them, even to those on the inside. In a good number of the accounts I come across, the prevalent way of making a claim is what you could call argument-by-moodboard. (AOC’s skincare-routine-as-political-key can’t compete.) I fully get it though. These layers of irony, this symbolic deflection—like owning a copy of the 1748 novel Clarissa and doing kettle-bell reps—not only allow for plausible deniability (‘it’s just a novel,’ ‘just an exercise routine’) but are honestly much more attractive than spending all day online and talking to the internet about hating women.

Another point of clarification: I do agree that modernity has its problems. I just firmly do not see the way out as backwards! And it is troubling to me that some of the public figures within these “return to tradition” communities are: 1. learning how to aesthetically encode their messages in a way that can communicate complex systems of hierarchies in a single image (as compared to the left’s tendency to relay complexity with long-winded, detailed language), and are 2. all but excited that, by default, their desired “beautiful” futures favor white men (and their subservient white female partners) above all. I find this repulsive and feel the need to warn everyone that this is the impression I'm getting here.

I struggle with my relationship with this content a lot. I generally don’t think one should attempt to stop art or, for that matter, any kind of creative expression. It’s also usually futile to try. But aesthetic literacy is a reasonable goal.


Giulio D'Anna, Il nuitatire (swimmer), 1930

When, in 1909, F. T. Marinetti published the first Futurist manifesto on the front page of Le Figaro, his embrace of mass cultural production and mechanical reproduction was seen as a thrilling pivot of the avant-garde (previously associated with bohemian enclaves). Ten years later, the Futurists—who, not unlike the aforementioned realm of the highly online, increasingly propagated chauvinistic “traditional” values—would become a mainstream political project that profoundly contributed to the formation of fascist ideology. But thanks to the Futurists’ status as avant-gardists on the one hand (popular conception of artists as good-hearted and socially progressive) and embrace of utopic-seeming technology on the other (progress free from the problems of irrational human bias!), their ideas enjoyed easy passage to the mainstream.

Hopefully I’m completely paranoid and this only looks like a growing issue to me because I'm online as much as I am. It's easy to forget that just 22% of Americans are on Twitter. But if this aesthetic turn is real, then an algorithmically reductive, systematized obsession with a regressive male ideal (and gendered counterpart) is being exported to the mainstream, encrypted in memes that critique modernity while claiming masculinity is a perfectible machine.

Laurent de La Hyre, Cornelia Rejecting the Crown of the Ptolemies, 1646

1.  It's important to remember, that Facebook did this in 2015. They launched a personal assistant named M, after acquiring Alex Lebrun's startup wit.ai, claiming it was a "human powered digital assistant." The idea was simple: have a chatbot handle the things for which there are API calls (Uber scheduling, checking the weather, etc.) and have a human do the hard stuff, with each exchange carried out entirely within the Messenger app. The "trick" was that the humans would record their method of solving more complex tasks and future iterations of the digital assistant would be trained on the solutions the human contractors found.

Unsurprisingly, the project shut down in 2018 with few details ever revealed, but one can imagine what a nightmare it must have been. I really would love to know how Facebook asked its (almost certainly minimum wage) contractors, whose job title was literally "trainer," to logged their "solutions" to complex tasks or how much money the company ultimately burnt on the project. We do have an estimate for the latter: fin.com, a company started by the co-founder of Venmo and (after M launched) an ex-VP of product at Facebook, was doing a chatbot assistant very similar to M, charging users $1/min with a minimum monthly spend of $120. They have since pivoted into a b2b analytics firm.

2. The majority of the content of this essay was written two weeks ago. Between then and now (while the piece was with NM being edited), there was a large fracture along the virgin/chad axis of the heavily online right, from what I can gather in part caused by Kantbot facedoxxing himself in Alex Lee Moyer's shitty documentary and the BAP crew finding that as good a time as any to separate themselves, calling KB fat and ugly.

It was always essential that at some point the kantbot/logo/etc ppl would have to define themselves against BAP style bc they are so opposed. The kantbot of “tfw no gf” is incompatible with the faceless semi-porno assemblage of beach model pics that comprises “BAP imaginary.” @mcrumps

I have a softer spot for KB and Logo than I do the BAP crew. Even if he wraps it in a larger, coded vision of the future, KB speaks about the problems of capitalism in a way that doesn’t diverge too far from leftists I appreciate. Meanwhile, the BAP crew’s philosophy just straight-up seems to be about gaining strength and power so as to not be a subservient Bugman; it’s as if the only selection pressure on their ideaspace is whether something makes you bigger and more bronze. (I can't wait for the first sun emoji Twitter person—a reference to the Black Sun—to get skin cancer due to "bronzing"...)

One last note on this topic before someone drags me: I am aware of how terrible Logo's poetry is (tho with this whole crowd it’s hard to tell when it’s trolling or serious or serious trolling, etc.) and that's not what I find concerning. Instead I'm thinking about how the idea of getting tan and muscular, and going outside with your hot girlfriend has mass appeal. And how this particular variant of the online right could be capable of seamlessly carrying its encrypted message to a much wider audience.


Duncan Wilson manages the hand tracking team at Ultraleap. He is based in the Bay Area. Comments and thoughts can be sent to dncnwlsn(at)protonmail.com and desk(at)newmodels.io.

Published: May 2020



NM 🔉 CHANNEL


UNLOCK MEMBER EPISODES...

via Substack $5/mo for 🇺🇸
via Patreon €5/mo (100+ eps) for rest of world
via Channel (coming soon)

LISTEN TO MORE PUBLIC EPISODES ...
Apple
Spotify
Soundcloud


THE NEW MODELS PODCAST

Full-length interviews with artists, scholars, and other experts

2024

NM76: K Allado-McDowell w/ K Allado-McDowell

NM75: Heavy Traffic magazine w/ its editor and publisher Patrick McGraw

2023

NM74: The Girlstack w/ theorist Alex Quicho

NM73: angelicism01’s Film01 w/ Lola Jusidman & Mateo Demarigny

NM72: Natasha Stagg on Artless: Stories 2019-2023


NM71: Silicon Age Mindset w/ Ribbonfarm’s Venkatesh Rao

NM70: Fantasm w/ Dorian Electra & Shumon Basar

NM70 (Bonus Track): Fantasm w/ Dorian Electra & Shumon Basar

NM69: Crude Futures w/ Richard Hames, Beau-Caprice Vetch, Jake Colvin

NM68: Psyberspace w/ artist Trevor Paglen

NM67: Metaverse Pastoral w/ artist Simon Denny

NM66: Cannibal Corp w/ Cory Doctorow

NMXX: Joshua Citarella x Lil Internet re/ physics of social media

NM65: U Wasn’t There w/ artist & filmmaker Ben Solomon on inter-millennial NYC

NMXX: Joshua Citarella x Carly re/ media and the public sphere

NM64: Infinite Drake w/ artists Holly Herndon & Mat Dryhurst

NM63: Loss of Distinction w/ art critic Ben Davis

NM62: How to Blow Up A Pipeline w/ filmmaker Daniel Goldhaber

NM61: Dubai’s Next Top Model w/ futurist Noah Raford & writer Shumon Basar

NM60: Code Couture w/ writer Olivia Kan-Sperling on the programming logic of style

NM59: 4-EVER-DIS w/ DIS’s Lauren Boyle

NM58: Public Access w/ artist Cory Arcangel

NM57: The Redescribers w/ political scientist Kevin Munger 

2022

NM56: The Para-Real w/ Cade Diehm of New Design Congress

NM55: Viral.rip w/ artist Kreayshawn aka Natassia Gail Zolot

NM54: Damn Nation w/ journalist James Pogue

NM53: Notes on Evil w/ artist Steven Warwick

NM52: Mallhammer 40K w/ artist Jon Rafman

NM51: Creator Core w/ artists Joshua Citarella & Rachel Rossin

NM50: Drug Update 2022 w/ drug & nightlife journalist Michelle Lhooq

NM49: GPT-Ditto w/ creative dir. Ben Ditto

NM48: Model Shock w/ art historian Emmelyn Butterfield-Rosen (author of Modern Art & the Remaking of the Human Disposition)

NM47: Mise en TV w/ artist Calla Henkel (author of Other People's Clothes)

NM46: Boomocracy w/ Kevin Munger (author of Generation Gap) on generational power in America

NM45: Shady Miladys w/ @holyyyycow & @davidy

NM44: Depeche Modem w/ Kevin Driscoll (author of The Modem World) on early net culture

NM43: After Dark w/ Shumon Basar & Dean Kissick on HSTRY2

NM42: Atomic User w/ Svitlana Matviyenko (co-author of Cyberwar & Revolution) on nuclear power & int'l security

NM41: Eco-Tomorrow w/ Sam Moore re/ his 2022 book, The Rise of Ecofascism

2021

NM40: Now in 4-D w/ Nora Khan & Joel Kuennen re/ algorithms & deep time

NM39: Paintings by Numbers w/ @jerrygogosian's Hilde Lynn Helphenstein and Matthew Capasso

NM38: Universal Basic Planetary Services w/ Benjamin Bratton

NM37: Game Start w/ Highsnobiety's Thom Bettridge and Civilization's Lucas Mascatello, Richard Turley re/ gaming, fashion & the real

NM36: Happy Medium w/ architectural theorist Keller Easterling re/ her 2021 book Medium Design

NM35: Net Povera w/ artist Joshua Citarella

NM34: Let There Be Light w/ The Cobra Snake

NM33: Imagination Nation w/ Richard Beck on moral panics

2020

NM32: Click, Click, Boom w/ Tim Hwang on attention, advertising

NM31: Power Strip w/ artist Simon Denny

NM30: Harm Reduction w/ Katharine Neill Harris on drug policy

NM29: Sad Frog w/ "Feels Good Man" (Pepe) filmmakers, Arthur Jones & Giorgio Angelini

NM28: Take It, It's Yours w/ Joshua Clover on looting & protest

NM27: Trend Consoloing w/ Thom Bettridge

NM26: Remote Learning w/ Nora Khan

NM25: Life Go Brrr w/ Venkatesh Rao

NM24: It's All Possible w/ TrueAnon's Liz Franczak

NM23: Disease & Metaphor w/ Mariam Ghani & Marisa Mazria Katz

NM22: Real Magick w/ Alex Kazemi

NM21: Elliot Rodger Plays Himself w/ Mike Crumplar

2019

NM20: Guest List w/ Natasha Stagg

NM19: The Flourishing w/ Tom Krell, aka How to Dress Well

NM18: Yung Matrix w/ Trevor McFedries of Brud on AR & marketing

NM17: Nonfood [+Bonus] w/ Lucy Chinen & Sean Raspet on food futures

NM16: E Pluribus Zuck w/ Mat Dryhurst & Kei Kreutler on FB's Libra coin

NM15: Remote Port w/ Benjamin Bratton on Earth's systems

NM14: Shift Alt Right Clique w/ Joshua Citarella on Irony Politics & Gen Z

NM13: Je Refuse w/ Jenny Odell on Attention and Refusal

NM12: Black Socialists w/ Z from Black Socialists of America

NM11: Downstram w/ Liz Pelly on cultural production, platforms, independence

NM10: Loose Climate Change w/ Christine Lariviere

NM9: Stack Attack w/ Cade on digital dark patterns

2018

NM8: Manplay w/ Ed Fornieles

NM7: Authenticity Dungeon w/ Toby Shorin

NM6: Teenage Radicals w/ Joshua Citarella

NM5: Unrealestate w/ Mat Dryhurst, Martti Kalliala, Michelle Lhooq

NM4: Psy-Trans Synth & Baselines w/ Anke Dyes, Steven Warwick, Ziúr

NM Pod 3: Lying Gods of Digital Tribes

NM Pod 2: Incels Modeling Agency

NM Pod 1: Feedcrafting w/ Carly Busta, Daniel Keller, @LILINTERNET


ABOUT


NEW MODELS
 is a media channel and community addressing the emergent effects of networked technology on culture. Est. 2018, Berlin.

NM pods are hosted by Caroline BustaLil Internet, Daniel Keller.

The NM community is a digital local distributed worldwide via Discord with light leaks to the dark side of newmodels.io and maintained by Leïth Benkhedda

In summer 2021, the NM community published the NM Codex Y2K20 and the NM Webdex.

Join via: Patreon or Substack
Join: Channel

Contact: desk(at)newmodels.io
Advertising: ads(at)newmodels.io


Website design: Jon Lucas
Logo: Jon Lucas & Eric Wrenn



SELECTED PRESS / INTVWS / ETC

2021


HIGHArt by highsnobiety, What Does the Internet Smell Like? (w/ Philip Maughan)

Index Magazine, Online Futures: What's Next for the World Wide Web — New Models (Caroline Busta, Lil Internet), Trust (Arthur Röing Baer, Joanna Pope), and Other Internet (Toby Shorin) in conversation with Anna Dorothea Ker

Kaleidoscope, American Memetics (Joshua Citarella, Caroline Busta, Daniel Keller, Lil Internet)

KW's Open Secret, Losing Yourself in the Dark (Caroline Busta)

Document, The Internet Didn't Kill Counterculture—You Just Won't Find it on Instagram (Caroline Busta)
CTM 2021, Possible Futures of Music Valuation — Cherie Hu, Jean-Hugues Kabuiku, Trevor McFedries; mod. New Models (Caroline Busta, Lil Internet)

2020


Kaleidoscope, Influencing the Void: How the Art World Lost the Thread (Caroline Busta)

HIGHTech by highsnobiety, Club Future: A Tour of Posisble Worlds with Berlin's New Models (w/ Philip Maughan)

2019


Shure.24, Interview with New Models

Novembre New Models (feat: photography by Ilya Lipkin, text by Ida Eritsland, design/layout by Betty Wang)

2018


TANK Magazine, "A podcast and anti-algorithm media platform covering contemporary topics at the bleeding edge of art, politics and culture"

FAST Company, New Models is the Intellectual Drudge Report for Critical Theory (Cale Guthrie Weissman)

ART News, Aggregate This!: Caroline Busta and Lil Internet on New Models, Their Art-Tech Answer to the Drudge Report (John Chiaverina)


CHANNEL



WHAT IS CHANNEL?

Channel
is a decentralized media organization and platform that allows creators to use Web 3 tools to work collectively, bundling content while maintaining distinct communities.

For the purposes of New Models, Channel is a membership and distribution meta-layer shared with two creators that we greatly respect and that have been central to our thinking since NM's inception: Joshua Citarella and Interdependence (Mat Dryhurst, Holly Herndon).


WHO IS BUILDING CHANNEL?

Interdependence
 (Mat Dryhurst, Holly Herndon), New Models (Caroline Busta, Daniel Keller, Lil Internet), and Joshua Citarella - working in partnership with Duncan WilsonCullen Miller, and James Geary.


IS THERE MORE INFORMATION?
https://channel.xyz
Twitter: @channel


NM DISPATCH

Reflections on the everyday

2023

NM Dispatch: America Diaries 12/2023 by Lilinternet

NM Communiqué: Notes on War 23.11.2023 by Lil Internet & Carly Busta

NM Dispatch: Dubai Diaries 2023 by Lil Internet & Carly Busta

NM Dispatch: America Diaries AW2023 (mini-bonus ep) by Ian Beckman Reagan

NM Dispatch: America Diaries AW2023 (Pt. 2) by LILINTERNET

NM Dispatch: America Diaries AW2023 (Pt. 1) by Carly Busta

2022

NM Dispatch: America Diaries (Pt. 2 of 2) by Lil Internet

NM Dispatch: America Diaries (Pt. 1 of 2) “Real Engine” by Carly Busta


RADIO PLAYS by LIL INTERNET

Elon Musk: 2040 / 69 (2023)

Ricky Backtrace, Private Trend Consultant - Ep 3 (2022)

Ricky Backtrace, Private Trend Consultant - Ep 2 (2022)

Ricky Backtrace, Private Trend Consultant - Ep 1 (2022)

Baddieverse (2022)

NFT Dreams (2021)

A Meditation on FOMO (2020)


NM SPECIAL REPORTS

On-the-ground, first-person reports re/ current events & focused points of interest

2024

NM Special Report: Ye and the Future of Content w/ Dean Kissick

2023

NM Special Report: Burning Man Blockade w/ Michelle Lhooq

NM Special Report: NYScene Update w/ Madeline Cash, chloé waifmaterial, David Yoakum

NM Special Report: Paradigm Trilogy II w/ Kat Korbjuhn

2022

NM Special Report: Bonn After Hours w/ artists Dena Yago & Joshua Citarella

NM Special Report: Pret-à-Panique w/ Dean Kissick on Balenciagagate

NM Special Report: documenta 15 w/ Paige K. Bradley, @abe1x, Felix Ansmann

NM Special Report: Digital Resilience & War w/ Cade Diehm

NM Special Report: Open Source Intelligence & Ukraine w/ @pdthorn

NM Special Report: Kyiv Update (8. Feb.) w/ Anastasiya Osipova

2021

NM Special Report: NM UX w/ NM's web designer Jon Lucas

NM Special Report: The Wedding Album w/ Carly & Lil Net <3

NM Special Report: Ambient Value w/ James Whipple (M.E.S.H.) re/ art NFTs

NM Special Report: Capitol Hill Insurrection w/ filmmaker Tomi Faison re/ Jan. 6th riots in Washington DC

2020

NM Special Report: Uncanny Rally w/ Jak Ritger, Clack Auden re/ techniques of crowd-staging and opinion manipulation

NM Special Report: George Floyd, Minneapolis Unrest w/ journalist Steve Marsh

Earlier

NM Special Report: Black Socialists launch Dual Power Map w/ Z from Black Socialists of America (2019)

NM Special Report: Revolution in the US Democratic Ranks w/ Mike Pepi (2018)


NM SHORTS

New models detected and unpacked in 30-min or less

NM Short: Lil Internet's VICE Interrupted (2024)

NM Short: Carly & Lil Internet on Jordan Wolfson’s “Body Sculpture” (2024)

NM Short: Out of the MUD by Lil Internet (2023)

NM Short:  Lil Internet’s Notes on Belly (1998, dir. Hype Williams) (2023)

NM Short: Indie Sleaze w/ fashion editor Taylore Scarabelli (2022)

NM Short: Cryptoverse w/ artist Bjarne Melgaard (2022)


NM GREENROOM

Musicians and other creators in the NM sphere discuss their new work.

NM Greenroom: Dances With White Girls aka Frog (2022)

NM Greenroom: ADR aka Aaron David Ross (2021)

NM Greenroom: Paradigm Trilogy w/ Katharina Korbjuhn (2021)

NM Greenroom: Lyra Pramuk (2020)

NM Greenroom: Steven Warwick (2019)


NM RECOMMENDS

Recent books by NM guests:

• Olivia Kan-Sperling, Island Time (2022, Expat Press)
• Emmelyn Butterfield-Rosen, Modern Art and the Remaking of Human Disposition (2021, Chicago)
• Kevin Munger, Generation Gap (2022, Columbia)
• Keving Driscoll, The Modem World (2022, Yale)
• Sam Moore, Alex Roberts, The Rise of Ecofascism (2022, Polity)
Calla Henkel, Other People's Clothes (2021, Sceptre/Doubleday)
S. Basar, D. Coupland, HUO, The Extreme Self (2021, Penguin)


COMMUNITY LEAKS


NM CREATOR NETWORK

INTERDEPENDENCE
JOSHUA CITARELLA
[DNR] DO NOT RESEARCH
TRUST


BULLETIN-BOARD


NM WEBDEX LAUNCH - 09 / 2021


NM CODEX LAUNCH - 07 / 2021


RESIDENCY: NM X HEAVY TRAFFIC

Selections from Heavy Traffic magazine, read aloud by their authors

NM x Heavy Traffic: Seth Price, "Machine Time" (Part 1)

NM x Heavy Traffic: Seth Price, "Machine Time" (Part 2)


NM TV

Kevin Munger on Vilém Flusser's Communicology: Mutations in Human Relations?

Richard Kennedy's Fubu Fukú, Trauma Bar und Kino, Berlin, 2020

What Does the Internet Smell Like? (NM x High Snobiety)


NM LECTURES

NM Lecture: Understanding Predicting Media — Global Art Forum, Dubai, 4 Mar 2023

NM Lecture: Do You Know Where You Live? — "Future of Criticism" Congress, Bundeskunsthalle Bonn, 18 Nov 2022

NM Lecture: Clearnet vs. Dark Forest: Notes on the New Psychogeoraphy of Art — UCLA Design Media Arts, 12 Mar 2021


NM TOPSOIL (2018-2022)

Talk-core with Carly, Lil Internet, and Daniel Keller re/ current events, tech, art, and pop culture. Many eps feature exclusive radio plays by LIL INTERNET and/or special guests.

2022

NM TopSoil 86: URBEXIT

NM TopSoil 85: Meta Daze

NM TopSoil 84: Art Basilisk w/ Alex Scrimgeour

NM TopSoil 83: Radio Active w/ Most Dismal Swamp

NM TopSoil 82: Kayfabe Capital

NM TopSoil 81: Palanpilled

NM TopSoil 80: Public Goods w/ Dan @ eth.denver

NM TopSoil 79: Dapp Rig w/ @chorist

NM TopSoil 78: Lootstrap

NM TopSoil 77: aka Topsoil 76 pt.2

NM TopSoil 76: pt.1 Read All Over w/ Cathal of NEWS/ACC

2021

NM TopSoil 75: Flightmare w/ Jöran Mandik of Radio Spätkauf on BER Airport

NM TopSoil 74: Back to the Land w/ Stephanie Wakefield

NM TopSoil 73: Meta Mindset w/ Hazmat Raheem

NM TopSoil 72: Swift Update

NM TopSoil 71: Keep on TRUC'n

NM TopSoil 70: Fulfilled by Taliban

NM TopSoil 69: Copening Ceremony

NM TopSoil 68: Danifest Destiny

NM TopSoil 67: No Whippits in Paradise

NM TopSoil 66-X: Earth Flatteners

NM TopSoil 66-X: Gram-Boss w/ @moma.ps5

NM TopSoil 65: Super League Prostate Exclusive

NM TopSoil 64: Prime of Life

NM TopSoil 63: Cargo Cult

NM TopSoil 62: Manicherial

NM TopSoil 61: Gate Analysis w/ Andrew Russeth

NM TopSoil 60: Cringe Core w/ Taylore Scarabelli

NM TopSoil 59: Ghost Face Shillah w/ @davidy

NM TopSoil 58: Virtue Signal

NM TopSoil 57: Capital Insurrection

NM TopSoil 56: Miami Based

NM TopSoil 55: Gloria

NM TopSoil 54: Capitol Gains w/ special report by Thomas Faison on Jan. 6th capitol attack

NM TopSoil 53: Stevia Jobs

2020

NM TopSoil 52: Power Broker

NM TopSoil 51: Crashocracy

NM TopSoil 50: Build Back Best

NM TopSoil 49: American Vibes

NM TopSoil 48: A Contest of Swords

NM TopSoil 47: Zapf Dingbats Are Real Life

NM TopSoil 46: Spiritual America

NM TopSoil 45: Mani/Pedo

NM TopSoil 44: Eternal Log

NM TopSoil 43: 3G Towne

NM TopSoil 42: Death by Exposure

NM TopSoil 41: Slide to the Left w/ Michell Lhooq

NM TopSoil 40: Mount Trashmore

NM TopSoil 39: Black Bloc

NM TopSoil 38: The German Dream

NM TopSoil 37: Querty

NM TopSoil 36: Sour Dough

NM TopSoil 35: Doral Futures

NM TopSoil 34: Sabbath Year

NM TopSoil 33: Escape From Moscow w/ Chiara Di Leone, Philip Maughan, Pierce Myers, Bryan Wolff

NM TopSoil 32: Silent Carry (MIAMI/LA/DFW/NYC/METAVERSE) pt. 1 w/ Stephanie Wakefield, Sean Monahan, Jean-Luc Vila, Natasha Stagg, Cade Diehm

NM TopSoil 32: Silent Carry (MIAMI/LA/DFW/NYC/METAVERSE) pt. 2 w/ Stephanie Wakefield, Sean Monahan, Jean-Luc Vila, Natasha Stagg, Cade Diehm

NM TopSoil 31: Corona Sands

NM TopSoil 30: Hole Adjacent w/ Eric Schwartau of Talk Hole & Lilnet's Mom

NM TopSoil 29: Quack is Whack

NM TopSoil 28: Of Froth & Virtue

NM TopSoil 27: Casino World

NM TopSoil 26: Wuhan Swimp Bod

NM TopSoil 25: One Night in Davos

NM TopSoil 24: Roger Stone's Intern

2019

NM TopSoil 23: Left Pill

NM TopSoil 22: Kim Bong-Un

NM TopSoil 21: This Machine Kills Algorithms

NM TopSoil 20: Collective Paranoia w/ Bjarne Melgaard

NM TopSoil 19: Ref Herring

NM TopSoil 18: Voluntourism

NM TopSoil 17: Kokopelli's Girlfriend

NM TopSoil 16: Luckey Strikes w/ Duncan Wilson

NM TopSoil 15: Unhack The Planet

NM TopSoil 14: Anna Got Me Clickin w/ Anna Khachiyan

NM TopSoil 13: Enlightenment Dan

NM TopSoil 12: Doomsday Dan

NM TopSoil 11: Epstein Smile

NM TopSoil 10: Big Face Saddams

NM TopSoil 9: The Real Housewives of Elysium w/ Dean Kissick

NM TopSoil 8: Valley of the Bros

NM TopSoil 7: Centrixxfuge

NM TopSoil 6: The Weirdening

NM TopSoil 5: Eastern Promises w/ Nik Kosmas

NM TopSoil 4: Buried Alive

NM TopSoil 3: Lawful Good

2018

NM TopSoil 2: Confusion

NM TopSoil 1: Internet Primacy Syndrome


NM COLLABS

NM x Society of Scent for Highsnobiety: Internet perfume (2021)
.
NM x Society of Scent - "The Internet" - for Highsnobiety (2021)

Bjarne Melgaard x New Models, Decade Brain, 2020 in Reena Spaulings NYC, "Sewars of Mars," 2020

NM HISTORY


TL;DR

NEW MODELS was founded in Berlin in 2018. It’s initial aim was to create a media space outside of the "physics" of Web 2.0 platforms by hand-aggregating links and seeding a community beyond the feed. In the time since, we have built an international member network and Discord server, staged many IRL and digital/physical events, published swarm-generated content with HighsnobietyKaleidoscope, and Novembre; released an album’s worth of unhinged radio plays by Lil Internet, created an Internet perfume with Society of Scent, and facilitated the creation of an interactive digital glossary (NM Webdex) and a physical book (NMCodex)—both collectively-authored by the NM community—indexing the experience of being online together during the extremely online year of Y2K20.



EXTENDED VERSION

NEW MODELS was founded in Berlin in 2018. Its initial aim was to think outside of Web 2.0 feeds by hand-aggregating a cache of information relevant to the culture sector ...



... particularly the ways in which networked technology was impacting the publishing, art, and music industries. We first used https://newmodels.io, as a kind of alt Drudge Report, with a contuously updated list of links and original commissioned NM content. / Search the NM archive: here.


We also hosted several physical events (many with Berlin's Trauma Bar und Kino, including NM Sim Society on world building and online identity formation and the premier of Richard Kennedy's 2020 opera Fubu Fukú.

NM Sim Society, feat. Joshua Citarella and Cade, Trauma Bar und Kino, Berlin, January 2020



To unpack the themes articulated through the aggregation and editorial, we started an audio stream — the public New Models Podcast, featuring conversations with artists, academics, and other experts. We soon began subscription-gating some of our content via Patreon, introducing the NM TopSoil show for more free-form discussion about current events and radio plays by Lil Internet.




This small barrier (€5 / month) created a subscribing New Models Community... which in turn led to us to start a Discord server. Suddenly, New Models was no longer just a creator-to-audience stream, but a mainframe for processing information free from the extractive properties of Clearnet spaces. We began referring to this ecosystem as a "dark forest." (For more on the interplay of different digital realms, see Caroline Busta's Internet/counterculture text for Document Journal.)


Within the NM Discord, a local language formed — as well as initiatives aimed at "devirtualizing" traces of NM's digital enclave into something physical and therefore less vulnerable to erasure. In 2021, the NM community produced the NM Codex and the NM Webdex.


But throughout the wider sub-Web 2.0 strata, many more online enclaves were emerging. In part this was because the Clearnet space was growing ever more untenable: random account deading, feeds organized by algorithms optmizing for target-margets, wide fluctuations in access and reach. For NM, the problem to solve was no longer exiting legacy media or Web 2 but establishing a new, more resiliant network beyond them.


In late 2020, New Models, in collaboration with Joshua Citarella and Interdpendence Pod (Mat Dryhurst & Holly Herndon), began working with Duncan Wilson, Cullen Miller, and James Geary to develop web3 tools allowing creators to do just that.

Channel, which pre-launched in Jan 2022, is rethinking how content is valued, distributed, and consumed. MVP arriving late 2022.

Jak Ritger, illustration of interconnected dark forest, creator communities spilling into each other, sharing flows of content, 2021.


In equal parts, New Models creates content, community, and the structures that facilitate both. As media evolves, so too will New Models. <3


Channel Season 0 Founder NFT (Team Rolfes)


FOLLLOW / LIKE / SUBSCRIBE:

• NM PATREON
• NM SUBSTACK
CHANNEL 🌌

• YT: @newmodelsTV
• IG: @newmodels_io
• TW: @newmodels_io
• SC: @newmodels


SOME LEGACY LINKS (from prev. site)

LEARN: 📈How big is a BILLION?
LEARN: 📡Time-lapse of the Future. Journey to the End of Time
LEARN: 🌍Time-Lapse History MAP of the WORLD
SURF: 💻Society of Control
SURF: 💻What's on 🇨🇳Weibo ...
SURF: 💻A scatter-plot visualization of every music genre Spotify recognizes
SURF: 💻Art collector 🎨database, http://organic.software


SOME LEGACY SOURCES (from prev. NM site)

032C, Berlin
AAAAARG
AFFIDAVIT
AFRICA IS A COUNTRY
ART AGAINST ART, Berlin
ART in AMERICA
ARTFORUM
ART NEWS
ARTNET
BAFFLER
BIDOUN
BOMB, New York
BRAND-NEW-LIFE, Zürich
BROOKLYN RAIL
CIVILIZATION, New York
CREATIVE INDEPENDENT
COMMUNE
CONTEMPORARY ART DAILY
CONTEMPORARY ART WRITING DAILY
DIS.ART
DOCUMENT
DRUDGE REPORT
ECONOMIST
E-FLUX
DISSENT
FAST COMPANY
FILM COMMENT
FINANCIAL TIMES
FAILED ARCHITECTURE
FLASH ART, Milan
FRIEZE
GALAXIA Y2K
GREY ROOM
HACKER NEWS
INTERVIEW
JACOBITE
KALEIDOSCOPE
LA REVIEW of BOOKS
LIBRARY STACK
LOGIC
LONDON REVIEW of BOOKS
MAY REVUE, Paris
NEO-METABOLISM
N+1
NEW INQUIRY
NEW YORKER
NY REVIEW of BOOKS
NOĒMA
NOVEMBRE
OCTOBER
PARIS REVIEW
PIN-UP
POINT
QUIETUS
REAL LIFE
REDDIT
RHIZOME
RIBBON FARM
SELVA
SMALL PRESS
SPEX, Berlin
SPIKE, Berlin/Vienna
STARSHIP, Berlin
STRELKA MAGAZINE, Moscow
TANK, London
TEXTE ZUR KUNST, Berlin
TOPICAL CREAM, New York
TRIPLE CANOPY, New York
UBU WEB
VESTOJ
VIEWPOINT
X-TRA, Los Angeles


FOLLLOW / LIKE / SUBSCRIBE:

• NM PATREON
• NM SUBSTACK
CHANNEL 🌌

• YT: @newmodelsTV
• IG: @newmodels_io
• TW: @newmodels_io
• SC: @newmodels